The impact of modern-day piracy on total loss regarding seizure or capture in marine insurance

 The impact of modern-day piracy on total loss regarding seizure or capture in marine insurance Essay


The impact of modern-day piracy on total loss when it comes to seizure or perhaps capture in marine insurance

Name: Xiang Sun

Student ID: 822321

Tutor: Doctor Gotthard Gauci

The impact of modern-day piracy on total loss in the matter of seizure or capture in marine insurance

Term: Xiang Sunshine

Student ID: 822321

Instructor: Dr . Gotthard Gauci

A feuille submitted in partial completion of the requirements of the College or university of Plymouth For the level of Maritime and Marine Legislation

26th August 2010

School of Plymouth


This is to certify the fact that work submitted here is completed by the prospect Xiang Sunlight.

Candidate's personal and day


Supervisor's signature and date



This copy of texte has been offered on state that anyone that consults it really is understood to discover that its copyright rests with its creator and that simply no quotation from the dissertation without information derived from it may be released without the author's prior written consent.


After having studied a lot of courses for University of Plymouth, I use made the decision to follow the postgraduate course of Maritime and Underwater Law.

I would like to adopt this possibility to send my own thankfulness to numerous people who allowed me to in various methods.

At first, I want to say thanks to my texte supervisor Doctor Gotthard Gauci for his valuable advice and support throughout the procedure for my dissertation. Thanks head to Professor. Paul Todd who also helped me in lots of ways during my studies.

Superb thanks are due to my children for their insistent supports over my postgraduate study.

Different thanks head to my friends that have helped me in several ways.


Before, pirates usually acted completely, it was most likely that a yacht and freight would have recently been occupied and the crew and passengers on-ship would have been killed. However , modern-day piracy has developed to a modern business; a modern buccaneer usually takes proper care of the vessel, cargo and crew and holds these people until a demand for ransom is met.

In a situation of ransom, interested owners usually choose their insurance policies and try to recover such a payment of ransom as being a suing and labour charge or being a general normal act. However, loss of making caused by a piracy-related detention either with or perhaps without damage or damage incurred is mostly not protected in their sea insurance policies.

In regards to such a time delay, there are several issues raised inside the recent case of Masefield AG sixth is v Amlin Company Member Ltd where the ship Bunga Melati Dua was seized by the Somali cutthroat buccaneers in the Gulf of mexico of Aden and then on sale since a short order following the repayment of a ransom demanded by or around the behalf of the shipowner " MISC”. The principal purpose of this study is to examine this case in relation to the problems raised pertaining to the freight onboard the vessel Bunga Melati Dua, whether there is a total damage on the seizure by the Somali pirates and whether the payment of ransom was unlike public insurance plan and if it should be regarded as in the framework of s57 (1) and s60 (1) of the MIA 1906.

List of Acronyms

ATL: Actual Total Damage

CTL: Beneficial Total Loss

ICC: Institute Shipment Clause

IMB: International Ocean going Bureau

K& R: Kidnap and Ransom

MIA: Sea Insurance Act

UNCLOS: Un Convention for the Law with the Seas


Chapter you: Introduction

1 ) 1 The setting:

Piracy in shipping is an international ocean going problem; it appears in various forms. Pirates might perform as a criminal company in order to hijack or get hold of possession of the subject-matters intended for ransom. Though this extraordinary form features existed for a long time, in recent years, piracy attacks intended for ransoms are becoming an unprecedented issue in shipping business...

Bibliography: Bennett, L., The Law of Marine Insurance, (2006, subsequent Edition, Oxford, Oxford University or college Press)

Dahir, D., ‘Jurisdictional challenges in handling piracy in the Gulf of Aden', (2009) 14 (2) Coventry Rules Journal pp. 23 – 27

Dunn, C., ‘Paying ransoms not illegitimate, ' Maritime Risk Intercontinental, 13 Apr 2010

Findarticles - Piracy's impact on insurance, (2009);col1 [Access in: 15/August 2010]

Gauci, G., ‘The requirement to file suit and labour in the regulation of marine insurance – time to amend the statutory provisions? ' (2000) The International Journal of Shipping and delivery Law, pp. 1 – 10, 87 -94.

Hodges, S., Instances and Materials on Sea Insurance Regulation, (1999, Birmingham, Cavendish Submitting Limited)

Hodges, S., Legislation of Sea Insurance, (1996, London, Cavendish Publishing Limited)

Lambeth, R., Templeman on Sea Insurance – Its Rules and Practice, (1986, sixth Edition, London, Pitman Creating Limited)

Mungo, Farreneheit., ‘Counteracting piracy, ' Ocean going Risk Worldwide, 10 August 2009

Rose, F., Marine Insurance: Rules and Practice, (2004, Greater london, Informa Profesional)

Drive, J., ‘Piracy and standard average, ' Maritime Risk International, summer October 2009

Talley, T., Maritime Protection Security and Piracy, (2008, 1st Model, London, Lloyd's List)

Todd, P., ‘Piracy for ransom: insurance issues', (2009) 15(4) Diary of Foreign Maritime Law pp